Welcome Guest Login or Signup
The Collectible Game Player Community
MY ACCOUNT -:- BLOGS -:- USERS -:- GALLERY -:- FORUM -:- GROUPS -:- POLLS -:- QUIZZES
midi2304
PROFILE   GALLERY   BLOGS   GUESTBOOK   FRIENDS   FAVORITES  
 


RSS
On The Bubble #3 - First Impressions
Posted On: 09/30/2007 16:33:10

So, I went to the prerelease today. Here's my pool...


White

 

Oblivion Ring

Springjack Knight

Kinsbaile Skirmisher

Wellgabber Apothercary

Cenn's Heir

Triclopean Sight

Plover Knights

Knight of Meadowgrain

Kinsbaile Ballonist x2

Wizened Cenn

Burrenton Forge-Tender

Lairwatch Giant

Surge of Thoughtweft

Hillcomber Giant


Blue


Paperfin Rascal x2

Ringskipper

Protective Bubble

Aquitect's Will

Streambed Aquitects

Mulldrifter

Ponder

Familiar's Ruse

Drowner of Secrets x2

Spellstutter Sprite

Wings of Velis Vel

Glimmerdust Nap


Black


Weed Strangle

Skeletal Changeling

Thorntooth Witch x2

Moonglove Winnower x2

Nameless Inversion

Peppersmoke

Black Poplar Shaman

Warren Pilferers

Eyeblight's Ending

Spiderwig Boggart

Bog Hoodlums

Facevaulter

Prowess of the Fair

Scarred Vinebreeder

Hunter of Eyeblights


Red


Wild Ricochet

Boggart Forager x2

Soulbright Flamekin x2

Glarewielder

Rebellion of the Flamekin

Blind-Spot Giant

Inner-Flame Acolyte x2

Smokebraider

Caterwailing Boggart

Flamekin Bladewhirl

Fire-Belly Changeling

Changeling Beserker

Mudbutton Torchrunner

Hurly-Burly

Stinkdrinker Daredevil


Green


Incremental Growth

Woodland Guidance

Heal the Scars

Eyes of the Wisent

Sylvan Echoes

Warren-Scourge Elf

Hunt Down x2

Elvish Eulogist

Spring Cleaning

Nath's Elite

Briarhorn

Gilt-Leaf Ambush x2

Kithkin Daggerdare

Battlewand Oak

Woodland Changeling

Cloudcrown Oak

Treefolk Harbinger


Gold


Doran, the Siege Tower


Lands and Artifacts


Vivid Meadow

Secluded Glen

Ancient Amphitheater

Shelldock Isle

Deathrender

Wanderer's Twig

 

Answer's on a postcard people... Here's what I went with for what it's worth...

 

Briarhorn

Gilt-Leaf Ambush x2

Kithkin Daggerdare

Battlewand Oak

Woodland Changeling

Cloudcrown Oak

Treefolk Harbinger

Weed Strangle

Skeletal Changeling

Thorntooth Witch x2

Moonglove Winnower x2

Nameless Inversion

Peppersmoke

Black Poplar Shaman

Warren Pilferers

Eyeblight's Ending

Oblivion Ring

Doran, The Siege Tower

Deathrender

Wanderer's Twing

Vivid Meadow

Plains

Swamp x8

Forest x7

 

No Planeswalkers and no Elemental Incarnations!

 
Blue didn't appeal at all - there was just no depth. Red looked ok, but for some reason I'm not really sure of myself at the moment, I don't like red in Lorwyn. It just seems to be lacking somehow.


It might just be Doran that made me think that though. I mean, c'mon, there was just no way I wasn't running that bad boy.


It was a tough call which other colour to cut - I think there was a decent GW, BW and BG deck in there, each splashing the third if necessary. In the end, I wanted the removal of black coupled with the Treefolk which were predominately in green. I didn't include Hunter of Eyeblights. Not sure whether or not that was a mistake or not to be honest.


So how did the deck do? Well there were 20 of us meaning five rounds of competition. I got beaten black and blue in the first match from a Bog-Strider Ash piloted very, very well by young Rita Jappy. Each game my removal had been sucked up. Indeed, in game 2, I had already cast Doran before she cast Ash, making for a very short clock.


From there, I managed to win out finishing a respectable 4-1, good for 4th out of the 20 taking part. I'm not sure the deck is actually as good as the record all of the same. Losing the first round and being in the bottom bracket for the next few meant the deck had less of a challenge than it otherwise may have. Oh well, you can only beat who you are drawn against.


I'd appreciate some ideas on how you guys would build the deck.


And first impressions of Lorwyn? Well, I haven't had the opportunity to draft it and that is something to look forward to. My gut feels that this set is very, very Timmy. It seems to lack some of the subtleness and ingenuity of Ravnica and Time Spiral Sealed. That may improve with Morningtide added to the mix.


I also noticed a lot of games going to time with stalled boards. I think this has a lot to do with the quality of removal in the set. I'll be talking more about that in my coming TCGpprentice article. I want to thank everyone who has taken the time to give me feedback so far in the contest. It really has helped me no end. Hopefully you'll see for yourself when my Task Two hits the front page.


Anyways, thanks for reading.

 

-Flame on-

Dave



Bookmark:



Viewing 1 - 2 out of 2 Comments

10/08/2007 02:00:59
I would say that the draws were about the same as usual. The Sunday flight actually went rather quickly, as we had our end of round bonus time down to ten to fifteen at one point (Prereleases often go 20 plus minutes due to lots of reading of cards).


10/03/2007 15:55:53
Hmm. I didn't see many games go to time, and I saw alot of opportunities for subtle play and good drafting to outdo bombs (in draft natch). Ishared your opinion about the "timmyness" of the set until I drafted. Now I think the set is very well crafted for that format (except for gilt-leaf ambush.)



*** MyTCGplayer ***